By Chandra Harris-McCray
David and Vera Mefford are fulfilling the lifelong quest of the late, world-renowned philosopher Robert S. Hartman to answer the question, "What is good?"
Hartman planted seeds of goodness in David, even before he had any realization he wanted to pursue a philosophy degree.
"Like many college students, I was just going about my educational career, not really sure what I wanted to do when I heard about this guy," explained David of his days as a student at the University of Tennessee. "People could not stop talking about him and his work. I had to get into one of his graduate classes to see and hear what all the talk was about."
He not only got into his class, but "I became Dr. Hartman's disciple and teaching assistant," says David. He became a philosophy major in 1967—the same year UT hired Hartman as a philosophy research professor.
David advanced his education by taking a European axiology class at the University of Paris and in 1976 he earned his magister artium degree in psychology, philosophy and law at the University of Heidelberg in Germany. But no one captivated him like Hartman, "because his work created the foundation for a logic-based system to determine personality differences based on an individual's value system," David says.
Quantifying the Immeasurable
Vera noted the major difference between psychological and axiological foundations: "Psychology is based mainly on an empirical foundation while axiology is based on a mathematical foundation. This is what gives us the capacity to quantify quality."
David said, "The Hartman Value Profile, an inventory assessment which measures with exactness the character and decision-making capacity of an individual, is not only extraordinary, but it still holds great value today.
"The five-year experience of studying with Hartman not only changed my life, it became my life," David said.
While working toward his doctorate, David worked as Hartman's assistant. During his studies, he evaluated and counseled psychiatric patients using the Hartman Value Profile. His dissertation, "Phenomenology of Man as a Valuing Subject" achieved a comprehensive typology of personality, based on value judgment patterns. The nondescript 210-page bound book, which details the axiological model of 26 cognitive types and 40 emotional temperaments, sits on his coffee table next to a family photo album.
He said, "After receiving my Ph.D. from UT, I went into business selling and promoting axiological products, especially the Hartman Value Profile."
Hartman's value concepts have been used in some of the largest corporations in the country to develop leadership excellence among top-level executives. Also, Hartman's extensive work in promoting profit sharing became the basis for today's 401(k) retirement saving plans.
A Radical and a Progressive
Even as a school boy in the Germany of Kaiser Wilhelm II, Hartman sought answers to help preserve and enhance the value of human life. He was required, as part of his school day, to repeat the loyalty oath: "I was born to die for Germany." Instead of believing it, he was convinced that the oath was false. Vocal about rejecting all violent creeds—whether of Communism, Nazism, or Fascism—Hartman was forced to leave Germany to escape imprisonment.
Hartman's career included professorship posts at Lake Forest Academy in Illinois, Ohio's College of Wooster, Ohio State University, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, and Yale. He conducted more than 50 lectures in the United States, Canada, Latin America, and Europe. The esteemed author of more than 10 books and 100 articles was a research professor of philosophy at UT and the National University of Mexico until his death in 1973.
"I have never known a more brilliant man nor a more creative mind in my life," said David, who is also a former UT philosophy instructor. "He was an excellent communicator and great teacher."
The Meffords hold fast to Hartman's work and character in their company, AXCES (Axiological Comprehensive Evaluation Systems).
"The foundation of my career stems from Hartman and his discovery of logic-based, frame-of-reference qualities," explained David, who is a co-founder and board member of the Robert S. Hartman Institute.
Giving Back to the Place Where it All Started
For more than three decades, David and his wife, Vera, have used the Hartman Value Profile as the foundation for creating a series of values-based personality instruments known as "targeted axiological profiles" and "values usage exercises." They are focused on developing industry-specific, axiological-based assessments, including applications for sports, fitness, business, finance, sales, leadership and hospitality, among many others. Their clients include professional sports teams, Chase Manhattan, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Alcoa Aluminum, Cellular One, and Target Training International.
A native of Morristown, David still calls the 16 acres where he grew up "home."
With a donkey, three horses, and 30 beehives, the Meffords enjoy the simpler things in life, especially after David was shot—and almost killed—22 years ago. A case of mistaken identity, the incident left indelible scars on David's chest that serve as a constant reminder that "life is precious-not material possessions," said Vera. "We do our best to make others more aware of how to live the 'good life' versus the 'goods life.'"
The couple decided that UT, "the place where it all started," mattered most when they bequeathed their estate to the College of Arts and Sciences to establish the Robert S. Hartman Endowment for Value Theory, which will provide UT's Department of Philosophy with much-needed support which includes a chair, graduate research fellowships, and a summer research fellowship. An interdisciplinary program to continue Hartman's work in value science is planned as well.
"All fields of study—law, medicine, business, athletics, education-can benefit greatly from applying this formal value theory," said Vera, who received her bachelor's degree from Houghton College in New York and her master's degree from Schiller University in Heidelberg, Germany. She also completed her master's post-graduate anthropological studies at the University of Heidelberg and attended graduate school at UT.
"We are here to help others grow their roots deeper and their branches higher," said Vera, "so when strong winds blow, their roots cannot be moved and their branches cannot be easily broken."
The information on this website is not intended as legal or tax advice. For such advice, please consult an attorney or tax advisor. Figures cited in examples are for hypothetical purposes only and are subject to change. References to estate and income taxes include federal taxes only. State income/estate taxes or state law may impact your results. Annuities are subject to regulation by the State of California. Payments under such agreements, however, are not protected or otherwise guaranteed by any government agency or the California Life and Health Insurance Guarantee Association. A charitable gift annuity is not regulated by the Oklahoma Insurance Department and is not protected by a guaranty association affiliated with the Oklahoma Insurance Department. Charitable gift annuities are not regulated by and are not under the jurisdiction of the South Dakota Division of Insurance.
A charitable bequest is one or two sentences in your will or living trust that leave to The University Of Tennessee a specific item, an amount of money, a gift contingent upon certain events or a percentage of your estate.
an individual or organization designated to receive benefits or funds under a will or other contract, such as an insurance policy, trust or retirement plan
"I, [name], of [city, state, ZIP], give, devise and bequeath to The University Of Tennessee [written amount or percentage of the estate or description of property] for its unrestricted use and purpose."
able to be changed or cancelled
A revocable living trust is set up during your lifetime and can be revoked at any time before death. They allow assets held in the trust to pass directly to beneficiaries without probate court proceedings and can also reduce federal estate taxes.
cannot be changed or cancelled
tax on gifts generally paid by the person making the gift rather than the recipient
the original value of an asset, such as stock, before its appreciation or depreciation
the growth in value of an asset like stock or real estate since the original purchase
the price a willing buyer and willing seller can agree on
The person receiving the gift annuity payments.
the part of an estate left after debts, taxes and specific bequests have been paid
a written and properly witnessed legal change to a will
the person named in a will to manage the estate, collect the property, pay any debt, and distribute property according to the will
A donor advised fund is an account that you set up but which is managed by a nonprofit organization. You contribute to the account, which grows tax-free. You can recommend how much (and how often) you want to distribute money from that fund to UT or other charities. You cannot direct the gifts.
An endowed gift can create a new endowment or add to an existing endowment. The principal of the endowment is invested and a portion of the principal’s earnings are used each year to support our mission.
Tax on the growth in value of an asset—such as real estate or stock—since its original purchase.
Securities, real estate, or any other property having a fair market value greater than its original purchase price.
Real estate can be a personal residence, vacation home, timeshare property, farm, commercial property or undeveloped land.
A charitable remainder trust provides you or other named individuals income each year for life or a period not exceeding 20 years from assets you give to the trust you create.
You give assets to a trust that pays our organization set payments for a number of years, which you choose. The longer the length of time, the better the gift tax savings to you. When the term is up, the remaining trust assets go to you, your family or other beneficiaries you select. This is an excellent way to transfer property to family members at a minimal cost.
You fund this type of trust with cash or appreciated assets—and receive an immediate federal income tax charitable deduction. You can also make additional gifts; each one also qualifies for a tax deduction. The trust pays you, each year, a variable amount based on a fixed percentage of the fair market value of the trust assets. When the trust terminates, the remaining principal goes to UT as a lump sum.
You fund this trust with cash or appreciated assets—and receive an immediate federal income tax charitable deduction. Each year the trust pays you or another named individual the same dollar amount you choose at the start. When the trust terminates, the remaining principal goes to UT as a lump sum.
A beneficiary designation clearly identifies how specific assets will be distributed after your death.
A charitable gift annuity involves a simple contract between you and UT where you agree to make a gift to UT and we, in return, agree to pay you (and someone else, if you choose) a fixed amount each year for the rest of your life.